ASA vs ABS: Which material to choose for durable prints

Two styrene materials for demanding tasks

For printing parts that must withstand higher temperatures or mechanical stress, styrene-based materials are often used. For many years, ABS was the standard. Today, its more modern relative, ASA, is coming to the forefront. Both plastics have a lot in common, but they differ fundamentally in several key properties. Below is a comparison and recommendations on when it makes sense to use which.

Transitioning from PLA or PETG to styrene materials requires preparation. These plastics require precise settings. The result is prints with a temperature resistance of 95 to 100 °C. This is the limit where common materials soften and lose their shape. Typical examples are car mounts, engine covers, or parts that remain in direct sunlight behind a window in summer.

Spool of ASA filament black, Prof. Lab, 1.75 mmSpool of ABS+ filament black, Prof. Lab, 1.75 mm
ASA and ABS+. Similar print settings, different uses.

What ASA and ABS have in common

The base of both materials is styrene. This gives them similar mechanical and thermal properties. Both ABS and ASA can withstand temperatures around 95 °C. They can be sanded, drilled, and cut without the plastic melting and sticking to the tool. Machining them is easier than with softer PETG.

They also share less favorable properties. The first of these is shrinking during cooling. When printing a larger model, the material tends to warp and lift from the build plate. This phenomenon is called warping. Larger prints cannot be successfully completed without an enclosed print chamber. Drafts or cooler air in the room will cause the layers to separate from each other, or the entire part to detach from the print sheet.

The second common property is odor and the release of fumes. Melting styrene plastics produces fumes. Safety during printing is absolutely essential. Printing should not occur in an unventilated room where people are present. The odor is pungent, and long-term inhalation of these particles is harmful to health. Always ventilate thoroughly and ideally use a printer equipped with air filtration. More details on this topic can be found in our article on 3D printing fumes.

Specifics of ABS material

The ABS material was one of the first plastics used in desktop 3D printing. Its main advantage today is primarily a lower purchase price and a specific property suitable for modelers. ABS can be easily and effectively smoothed with acetone vapor. For creating a glossy and smooth surface where print layers are not visible, ABS is a suitable choice. Acetone etches the surface layer of the plastic and merges it into a seamless whole. This process also strengthens the print in the Z axis, as the layers chemically bond.

Acetone smoothing has its rules. Acetone is highly flammable, and its vapors are dangerous. The process must be carried out in a well-ventilated area and with maximum caution. The result is suitable for visual models or parts that will be subsequently painted.

Print settings for ABS

For successful ABS printing, we recommend the following values. The nozzle temperature should be 230 to 260 °C. Heat the bed to 90 to 110 °C. For larger models, an enclosure, i.e., a closed print chamber, is recommended, otherwise warping occurs. Apply glue or a special spray to the bed so the model adheres well. The temperature resistance of the finished part is 95 to 100 °C. The material releases styrene, so ventilation is necessary. If the filament pops or forms bubbles during printing, it has absorbed moisture. Dry ABS at 80 °C for about 4 hours.

Specifics of ASA material

The ASA material was created as an answer to the shortcomings of ABS in outdoor use. ABS degrades quickly in the sun. It loses its strength, becomes brittle, and its colors yellow or fade. ASA solves this problem. It is resistant to UV radiation and weather conditions. For printing a birdhouse, an antenna mount, or any part for the garden, ASA is a suitable choice. It will last long-term in rain and sun without significantly becoming brittle or fading.

In our experience, ASA prints slightly better than ABS. Shrinkage is lower, although it still requires an enclosed chamber for larger parts. The odor during printing is less aggressive, but ventilation is still necessary. The fumes contain styrene and are harmful. ASA reacts with acetone, but smoothing does not work as reliably and cleanly as with ABS. The surface can sometimes become matte or leave white marks.

Print settings for ASA

For printing ASA, we recommend similar temperatures to ABS. The nozzle should be 240 to 260 °C and the bed 90 to 110 °C. An enclosed box is strongly recommended. Leave print cooling off, or set it to a maximum of 10 to 20 % for small details and overhangs. We recommend printing on a PEI sheet with a thin layer of glue applied. It serves as a separator so the surface of the sheet is not damaged when removing the print. The material releases styrene, so ventilate. Material moisture can be solved by drying at 80 °C for about 4 hours.

ASA and ABS overview

Relative rating 1 to 5 (higher = better) according to typical values and our printing experience.

ABS ASA
UV and weather resistanceASA
2
5
Temperature resistanceTie
4
4
Acetone smoothingABS
5
2
Warping resistanceASA
2
3
Less odor during printingASA
2
3
Lower priceABS
4
3
1: weaker5: best

Both materials release styrene during printing. Print them in an enclosed chamber and ventilate the room.

Comparison of properties in a table

For a better overview, we have prepared a table showing the main differences between the two materials. This helps in making a quick decision on which material to choose.

PropertyABSASA
Temperature resistance95 to 100 °C95 to 100 °C
UV resistanceLow (becomes brittle and yellows)High (ideal for outdoors)
Acetone smoothingExcellentWeaker, surface may become matte
WarpingHighMedium high
Odor during printingStrongMedium strong

When to choose which material

Deciding between ASA and ABS depends on the intended use. For printing a part that will be permanently outdoors, on a car, or in the sun, choose ASA. The higher price for this material is offset by the long lifespan of the print. We also recommend ASA for technical parts for the workshop, where easier printing and less warping are appreciated.

We recommend ABS in two cases. The first is the mass production of technical parts for interiors, where a lower price plays a role. The second reason is the need for a smooth surface. For smoothing models in acetone vapors, ABS is the most suitable choice. The resulting glossy surface resembles injection-molded plastic and cannot be easily achieved with other common materials.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

1. Can ASA and ABS be printed without an enclosed chamber?

Small models a few centimeters in size can be printed on an open printer. However, as soon as larger items are printed, the material will start to shrink and warp. Without an enclosure, the corners will lift from the bed and the layers may crack. An enclosed chamber is a necessity for reliable printing of these materials.

2. Can ASA be smoothed with acetone just like ABS?

ASA reacts with acetone, but the result is usually not as high quality as with ABS. The surface often does not shine evenly and matte white patches can form on it. We recommend ABS for chemical smoothing.

3. Which material is easier to print?

In our experience, ASA is slightly easier to print. It shrinks less and adheres better to the bed. The difference is not large, and both materials require a properly configured printer and a heated chamber.

4. How to properly dry these materials?

Both materials can absorb air moisture, which manifests as popping in the nozzle and a degraded print surface. We recommend using a filament dryer or a food dehydrator. Dry both ASA and ABS at 80 °C for about 4 hours. We do not recommend an oven, as the temperature in it fluctuates and the spool could be destroyed.

5. Why is glue necessary on a PEI bed?

With styrene materials, glue does not primarily serve to increase adhesion, but as a separation layer. Both ASA and ABS can adhere strongly to a smooth PEI surface. Without a thin layer of glue, there is a risk of damaging the bed surface when removing the print.